Whose Blog Is This?
Log onto Squarespace
« Toddler Nursing - Baby 3 | Main | Scheherazade Entry »


I've been pro-choice since I was about 10-years old. I was angrily pro-life until I read a "Letter to the Editor" my mother wrote about babies in dumpsters and children sexually and physically abused by their parents. I had an about-face and haven't looked back since. It was the only time I ever knew what my mother felt about abortion; I still have no idea how my dad feels.

Through the years, I helped friends in need and supported women as they made their decisions to terminate. It never phased me to go with them or sit with them post-abortion while they recovered or processed the experience.

Later, I worked at Planned Parenthood, listening to the women as they told me horribly painful stories of why they were choosing termination over adoption or keeping the baby. Women whispering about their own physical abuse, how they were forbidden to use birth control, yet knowing if they had another daughter, she would be fair game in the house as a sexual pet for dad. I listened as 14-year olds cried because their 23-year old boyfriends promised love and devotion, yet vanished upon hearing the pregnancy test was positive. I listened as a mom, pregnant with her fifth baby, despite meticulous use of the pill, was distraught over how to pay for yet another mouth in the house - she was trying so hard to get off welfare and make a life for her family.

Of course, knowing very pro-life folks, to them, these are still not valid reasons for terminating a pregnancy. While I respectfully disagree, they have the right to their beliefs.

My main job at Planned Parenthood wasn't as a pregnancy counselor, but as a prenatal case coordinator. I loved it and found the many levels of the position, which also included HIV counseling, stimulating and a way for me to really care for women who don't always have someone to care about them. Migrants and inner city teens continue holding a special place in my heart.

When the producers from 30 Days (a television show on F/X) contacted me about appearing on camera as a facilitator for others who've had abortions, I eagerly agreed.

I gathered together six women who'd had abortions, three of whom had had illegal abortions and three who'd had legal abortions. Some women had had more than one, one woman was in her eighties, another held a newborn in her arms. All but one had either had children before or after their abortions. It was poignant listening to the women sharing their stories of strength and desperation in a time when they felt so vulnerable. I was honored to be in their midst.

The camera crew was unobtrusive and they seemed to get some good footage. We'll see in a few more weeks as 30 Days unfolds on Wednesday nights at 10pm (ET/PT). Our show should be 4 weeks from yesterday.

After the taping, I was invited to the home for unwed mothers the woman, Jennifer, was staying in for 30 days. Run by a pastor and his wife, they house dozens of women who choose not to have abortions. I thought it would be a great opportunity to venture inside somewhere I never would have otherwise. I was in the car and on my way up to Los Angeles County before anyone could say, "Freedom of Choice."

There, I blinked, over and over, that I was standing inside a place that so despises abortion they stand outside clinics yelling at women, showing pictures that would make even the most cynical person ill (and that are NOT what aborted embryos/fetuses look like, by the way) and convince wavering women to wait and wait and wait until a choice is no longer possible. Evangelical Christian staff members quoted Scripture as did most of the walls in the very large compound.

Meeting with the pastor and his wife, we agreed first thing to not be mean to each other, to be respectful and to not bait or throw chairs. Over and over, they couldn't believe a midwife could possibly be pro-choice. I told them it was because I was a midwife and knew what birth was all about that I was pro-choice. I shared examples of situations (similar to those above) and listened as they shared equally harrowing examples of women who chose to continue their pregnancies. Neither of us changed our minds, but it was refreshing to spend time in discussion instead of the screaming so often seen in the media - and in front of clinics around the United States.

So, when someone very, very close to me came and said she wanted to terminate her pregnancy, my general reaction should have been one of acceptance and helpfulness, right? I am almost ashamed to say it wasn't. I talked with her at length, about all the three options and listened as she rationally laid out her reasons for wanting an abortion - she was making the right choice for her.

Privately, I cried.

I can rationalize it by knowing it is merely an embryo, not yet a newborn baby in an exhausted mother's arms, but I also know where that embryo would be if left alone for a few more months. I didn't expect to ever be this close to the other side of the debate.

Merely voicing my relationship with the baby-to-be allowed me to move past the sadness and into a place of support and information with the woman. I found the numbers she needed, bypassed the usual time-consuming waiting room sitting (thank goodness for Planned Parenthood connections) and the counseling by strangers and then left her to make the calls and get the assistance she needed to pay for the procedure. She is standing strong in her situation and I am proud to watch the maturity I don't always see.

She has asked me to go with her, hold her hand as the baby (okay, I said it) is removed from her body. Without crying, I told her I was there and supported her 100%. So do those around her, including her partner.

Writing this, tender tears fall, hoping the baby's spirit finds its way back into my life (and hers) at a more appropriate time. Ten years from now would be a good time.

Who knew this topic would elicit such conflicted feelings from such a die-hard pro-choice woman.

Maybe being a midwife blurs the edges more than I thought.

It isn't all or nothing anymore, is it.

References (3)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.

Reader Comments (8)

the same thing happened to me in the past couple weeks. a former client, a friend. it was so hard to hear her process as she made the choice. I accompanied her to the clinic, stood by and held her hand during the procedure and dropped her off at home with yummy mashed potatoes.

it's not easy. before kids, my idea of choice was black and white. it's always gray now. I will never stop being pro-choice, it's just that now faces and real situations are accompanied by the feeling.

August 3, 2006 | Unregistered CommenterSage Femme

I was pro-life/anti-abortion till my mid-20s, when I began to realize what having a baby really entailed in terms of being able to survive, in terms of being abused, in terms of having the government so intimately involved in your body. I've never had one, but I might need to one day, and I want them to be there if I do.

Having my son only confirmed my belief; no one should be forced to make the sacrifices I made willingly.

My analogy now is that if your boats sink on a regular basis, you don't throw away the lifeboats...you make them less necessary by fixing the boats. There are many good ways to reduce abortions that don't require putting anyone in jail, and if we were sensible, we'd have enacted them already.

August 3, 2006 | Unregistered Commenteremjaybee

I don't think there's all or nothing in anything these days - ethics and morality are becoming increasingly blurred. I sometimes wish I had a harder line on some things.

August 4, 2006 | Unregistered CommenterRebecca

Thank you for this post.
I too have seen the disbelief on the faces of women who can't possibly believe that a midwife can be pro-choice. But I have also felt the love and understanding of the women who can't believe a midwife could be anything but.

Helping a friend through an abortion is always tough. Because you love that person, you do grieve for what they might be missing out on by not carrying their baby. But you do what you know is right - which is love and support them through this difficult choice.

Thanks again

August 4, 2006 | Unregistered CommenterAnonymous

What a sensible and sensitive post. It is easier to empathize with someone who takes the opposite stance from you on abortion when both parties can recognize that the other has formulated their stance from a position of love and concern rather than hostility.

Coincidentally (or not), I just finished reading the chapter in Peggy Vincent's Baby Catcher where her young son tells her about "Spirit Babies" after an early miscarriage. For you and your loved one, I hope that this baby's spirit gets to "cut to the front of the line" if the opportunity comes around again.

August 4, 2006 | Unregistered CommenterNatalie

Wow...can I say I am the same, but opposite? I have always been pro-life, or what I have said is Pro-woman/Pro-baby (as Feminists for Life, an organization I am a member of calls it, and whose tagline is, "Women deserve better than abortion.")

However, I did a couple year stint in a Crisis Pregnancy Center, where it was forbotten to give even the suggestion of using birth control. I would be counselling with young girls (yes, girls) who had NO plan to be abstinent, who came in to see if they were pregnant. They'd get beat up and raped if they went home and told their boyfriend, "No."

I've always believed abortion to be wrong; now I find it to be a terrible last resort. I would always hope, if at all possible, for a solution other than abortion. I find it terribly hard to know that the baby has no choice in the matter. However, would I support a woman who chose abortion? Yes. Would I go WITH her and hold her hand? Yes.

Many shades of gray, as Sage Femme said. I've learned something else in my old age. Self-proclaimed Pro-choicers aren't PUSHING for abortion. Pro-choice folks give all three choices, just as I do. They hope that abortion won't be the decision. They don't WANT women to have abortions. They hope it's a last resort, too. Right?


I am pro-choice, but I still mourn the babies. I don't want women to have abortions, but if they feel that's what they need I suport it, even stronger now for the reasons emjaybee said. I think there are better ways to reduce the abortion figures than persecuting the women who choose them (because obviously that doesn't work). Changing the way society treats mothers, especially single mothers, would go a long way... as well as assisting them more with the care of their children. But that's for another time.

August 4, 2006 | Unregistered Commenteranastasia_wolf

Your compassion never ceases to amaze me. (hugs)

August 4, 2006 | Unregistered Commenterwanderglow

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.