Log onto Squarespace
Archives
« A Baby Died | Main | My Hernia »
Friday
Jan312014

My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"

I am not a Statistician so cannot speak about the stats in the study. What I can speak about is how the statistics were gathered and what that might mean about the whole study’s validity. 

My own statistics are a part of this study. I have filled out the paperwork not only for myself, but for other midwives as well. In fact, I have spent hours filling out the statistics paperwork, poring through charts, answering questions from the beginning of pregnancy through six weeks postpartum. 

The study says they enrolled the clients before they knew the outcome of the births, but I beg to differ. They may do that now, but back when I was doing them (2004-2009), we didn’t even fill out the paperwork until the woman was past six weeks postpartum. In fact, we used to sit with a pile of charts in our laps and fill out stat sheet after stat sheet, some women even a year (or more) postpartum. At that time, the stats were filled out on paper and sent in, so I know we weren’t supposed to send in any statistics before the woman was six weeks postpartum. I can’t imagine we were the only ones that did it that way. 

So, while there are parts of the statistics that are objective – whether the woman has a breech baby, twins or was a transport – there are other aspects where the answers to the questions are subjective. How long a woman’s labor was, how long she had Rupture of Membranes, the degree of her tear… are all areas where subjectivity come into play. You wouldn’t think so, but I have seen midwives lie in the chart (and then on the stats forms) about such things, not wanting the Powers That Be to know they let a woman with ROM labor for 32 hours without transferring her or that she sutured a third degree tear. I never saw charts be subjective when I worked with the CNMs in the two birth centers I worked at, but it was a distinct part of the midwifery culture I worked in as a CPM/LM. I know I stretched the truth myself when it came to extra long labors or trying to get the best blood pressure on a woman. 

As we know, the statistics gathering was completely voluntary. I knew several midwives who never did the stats; a few that did. And this was just in one city! How can anything really be known by such skewed statistics (if you even want to call them that anymore)? And I am sure that midwives with a bad outcome just didn’t finish that woman’s stats. It would have been encouraged in the culture. So that so many did send in negative outcomes lets us know how bad the perinatal mortality and morbidity rate really was. 

I look forward to more dissecting of the perinatal mortality part of the statistics being done. They don’t look good now. That so many are just taking what pro-home birth sites have to say about the study is frustrating. Look at the naysayers, too. 

I know it sounds like I am anti-home birth now, but there is nothing like that at all. I am still pro-home birth… with a highly trained and skilled midwife with a transport plan in place and supportive back up care. I am against breeches and twins at home births (as the study distinctly says should not happen at home!) and am slowly coming to see that even VBACs might not be best to do at home (after talking to HBAC loss moms). But, I do still believe in home births, just with some caveats. 

I, more than anyone else, would love to see a real study telling us about the safety of home birth, but this one sure is not it.

References (122)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.
  • Response
    I recently started a blog, and I was just wondering how people have promoted their blogs online to get more followers so you aren't just typing to nothing out in the internet?. Oh, and for my blog, I don't really want my friends to be my followers, unless they find it ...
  • Response
    I sign into my Tumblr account, and switch the dashboard from my main blog to the secondary blog, then I go to Account > Preferences > Customize your blog, but then it just takes me to the customization page for my main blog. Any way to customize my secondary blog, or ...
  • Response
    Response: iva help
    I have seen a lot of blogs in blogspot. What purpose do they serve? Is it possible to make money through blogs. If yes how?.
  • Response
    Im based in London have worked as a secretary for more than 10 years and have an HND in Business Studies but am tired of admin work and office politics and would like to do something more creative- change careers.. . I write in my spare time and have attended an ...
  • Response
    Response: code optimization
    How do I import Firefox bookmarks and other settings from one user account to another?
  • Response
    Response: mirena attorney
    I have a blog on Blogspot that I've been trying to customize with my own banner, but I can't seem to figure out where to do this :P A site where I could make a banner would be helpdul, too. If anyone has any directions they could give me to help ...
  • Response
    Response: seo services india
    How to change the preferences on a secondary Tumblr blog?
  • Response
    This made me giggle for an extended time.
  • Response
    How come my computer does not register the other computers in the network?
  • Response
    Im based in London have worked as a secretary for more than 10 years and have an HND in Business Studies but am tired of admin work and office politics and would like to do something more creative- change careers.. . I write in my spare time and have attended an ...
  • Response
    Response: selling bullion
    Im based in London have worked as a secretary for more than 10 years and have an HND in Business Studies but am tired of admin work and office politics and would like to do something more creative- change careers.. . I write in my spare time and have attended an ...
  • Response
    When trying to publish a book wouldn't you protect your story or content with a copyright?
  • Response
    Does a computer engineer play a important role in designing an aircraft ?
  • Response
    I just bought business plan pro, but I still don't quite understand how to estimate/compute the start-up costs for starting a business, in my case an online business at that. Is there a website that can assist me? Any suggestions? Thanks.
  • Response
    Response: silver investment
    How can i migrate from Joomla to Wordpress together with all my posts?
  • Response
    Response: buy gold bullion
    How to stop importing blog posts on facebook? 'Stop importing' button is not found.?
  • Response
    Response: light bulbs
    How do I start my own website about fantasy sports?
  • Response
    Response: Mike Honari
    How do I get "undefined" on my blog posts? There are 3 undefined words right below the title of my blog post. How do I get rid of it?.
  • Response
    Come on, tell me how you really feel.
  • Response
    How could I write blogs or articles and get paid for it?
  • Response
    How can I add a hit counter to my blogger blog? Detailed instructions would be appreciated. I searched counter on google and i can get this html code but i dont know what to do with it. Thanks!.
  • Response
    Response: pet vaccine
    My home computer is hooked up to a router. I would like to have access to my home computer's webcam through my work computer. . My home computer is hooked up through a DSL modem and is always on.. My work computer obviously has access to the Internet..
  • Response
    My home computer is hooked up to a router. I would like to have access to my home computer's webcam through my work computer. . My home computer is hooked up through a DSL modem and is always on.. My work computer obviously has access to the Internet..
  • Response
    Response: psychic scams
    Is there automatic and legitimate copyright for the content on a site?
  • Response
    Would becoming a paid blogger be a good idea to get money?
  • Response
    I am in an english class at the University of Tennessee and my professor stated that if one of us can get published our blog published on the website, we will get an automatic A in the course. Please, if anyone knows how you can get a blog published on Amnesty ...
  • Response
    Response: here.
    I see in my blog trackers significant traffic coming from facebook. My blog is not connected with facebook, I don't have an account there, and I can't see, who posts the links...any ideas?.
  • Response
    Response: homeowners
    I am from India. I did my Engineering in Computer Science. I had a made a poor career choice and regretting now.. . I am currently working as a Senior Software Engineer in one of the software firms.. . I wish to do MS in USA. But I dont want to ...
  • Response
    Response: your input here
    Can I share some links with copyright content on twitter?
  • Response
    Response: march madness 2014
    What is the best free software to automatically backup wordpress database and files?
  • Response
    How to make my second blog my default one on Tumblr?
  • Response
    Response: additional reading
    I put a WordPress blog on my website a few days ago, and I was just curious about how it works. So I just want to know if all the posts are saved into a single file or if they are separate for each post. Then I also want to know ...
  • Response
    Just bought a new laptop, not sure whether there is a way to take firefox bookmarks from old laptop to new laptop.. . Thanks..
  • Response
    What websites are for blogging only? Like writing journals but we can use a different name?
  • Response
    Response: on the main page
    How do I get my Wordpress blog posts to get views in the days after I first post them?
  • Response
    I've heard that there are some issues with character limits on the PS3 web browser. Has this problem been fixed? Would I be able to type out long blog posts on the PS3 web browser?.
  • Response
    I have a blog using Blogspot. I would like to ban a specific person from viewing and/or commenting. I am not looking to make the entire blog password-protected or moderate comments. I just want to ban a specific IP address. How can I do this?.
  • Response
    I'm into photography and would like to start selling my work and attracting more clients. My question is how would I go about starting a website where people can buy my photos or contact me about taking photos? I'm looking for a way to maximize my advertising and would really like ...
  • Response
    Response: read review
    i buy a domain and host and as subdomain i have a choice to creat a blog. i love to do it but i completely dazed!!! can anyone help me to make it right?. I buy a domain and host and as subdomain i have a choice to creat a blog. ...
  • Response
    Response: vehicle insurance
    I need 2 set up wordpess through a webhost.... . i know i have to download wordpress but whats a good host to go with? and after i set up an account with a host, how difficult is the set up before I can begin building a site? and last but ...
  • Response
    I want to start a website to post merchandise from home. Would a blog be fine? Or are there free sources for creating websites?.
  • Response
    Hi,. can enybody please tell me other platforms that blogger, wordpress, posterous, dupral where I can make blog posts by email?. I need a list of free blog services that allow you to make your post by email..
  • Response
    Response: homeowners policy
    How to transfer firefox bookmarks from one laptop to another laptop?
  • Response
    How long does a copyright last on newspaper articles?. . If a service copies newspapers articles and then posts it in a database on the Internet, is there also a copyright on the Internet content?.
  • Response
    Is it safe? . Safer than myspace?. Can you use myspace layouts for it?. How old do you how to be to have one?. . Please answer as many as possible . Thanx :].
  • Response
    They are noteworthy for the possibly of the making of a book..
  • Response
    How to stop Firefox download window from popping up in Mac?
  • Response
    Response: find more info
    What is the best blogging platform for a podcast or a video blog?
  • Response
    Response: right here
    I updated to the latest version, and now it keeps on coming up with that tab whenever i startup firefox. What should i do?. I have updated it, there is a tab saying that i have, that is the problem. It is telling me all of the new features that this ...
  • Response
    Response: infoludek
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    Response: view website
    How can I find who publish links from my blog posts to facebook?
  • Response
    How come I get this ? when using Firefox and when I am using Internet Explorer shows what I am supposed to get, (Wed) ,as the text. If you cannot see what I put down it is a small box with the numbers 26 and 20 inside of it.. Is there ...
  • Response
    I've heard you can make money off of advertisers. Is it really a significant enough amount to make it worth it? Or does the real benefit in blogging come from the exposure you get? I'm a bellydancer and I dance at private parties and events. How could I use a blog ...
  • Response
    Whenever i start a video call/ web cam/voice call on live messenger, skype, google talk, yahoo messenger, my computer totally freezes, and gives an echo. I have to restart it manually. Sometimes it comes with a blue screen, and it restarts itself.. I am using Vista, and this situation existed when ...
  • Response
    What happens to files when my wordpress space upgrade expires?
  • Response
    What are the best colleges for creative writing and screenwriting?
  • Response
    How do IE and Firefox make money? Where is the revenue source coming in from?
  • Response
    Response: find out here
    How do I start and use a blog? Also, what is the best blogging site?
  • Response
    How do I remove an image from my blogger sidebar?
  • Response
    Response: index
    I am interested in advertising a new social networking site. I have never wrote a Blog before. How should I write this? . And where do I go to write a Blog. This is all new to me and I want to start rocking.. Thanks..
  • Response
    Response: secret info
    On my friend's blogs they have added me on their blog rolls, but mine always sits at the bottom of the list and does not list when I post like it does for others. Is this a setting that I need to change or is this a choice that they have ...
  • Response
    I want to start a blog written by a fictitious character commenting on politics, current events, news etc..How?.
  • Response
    What are some great ideas on teaching creative writing to kids?
  • Response
    Response: click
    Can I start a blog that has recording of bad customer service?
  • Response
    I have a blog on a custom domain and I only want my Family to be able to see it using a Password using Google's Blogger!.
  • Response
    Response: cheap army boots
    How do I go about removing articles that breach copyright?
  • Response
    Response: enquiry
    How do I make my previous Yahoo 360 blog posts visible to the public?
  • Response
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    I want to start a blog written by a fictitious character commenting on politics, current events, news etc..How?.
  • Response
    In other words, how do i search for blogs that fit what I want to read about? Does anyone know how to BROWSE through blogs by subject or whatever on blogger?.
  • Response
    Can you translate and post articles online from foreign news/magazines without fear of copyright infringement?
  • Response
    Response: miami seo
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    Response: pizza hut coupons
    I am planning on being a creative writing teacher for my Senior project. The problem is, I can't think of a grade that kids start creative writing. I would rather deal with younger kids than older ones because in the end I want to give them a book of the classes ...
  • Response
    I have a lot of bookmarked websites part of Blogspot that I check daily for updates, but it is so annoying to click through a list. If I make an account is there some sort of feature where I can see new posts on the websites? (Sort of like Subscriptions on ...
  • Response
    I am thinking about becoming a 'ProBlogger". I know Blogging is a very slow business, but still i want to know how much time will it take me to start earning at least $100.. I can work everyday for approximately 11 hrs. Can i expect start earning $100 within two months.. ...
  • Response
    Hi. I'm looking for a good site that offers creative writing prompts or creative writing exercises since I heard that anyone who is serious about writing should do creative writing exercises. So does anyone know of a good one?.
  • Response
    Response: seo firm new york
    The greatest students of color work anywhere
  • Response
    Response: read more
    I'm a writer and I would love to have people's opinions on my work. Does anyone know any good blogging sites?. Twitter is not a blogging site and the only way people see your work on twitter is if they follow you. Twitter and Facebook are not answers that I am ...
  • Response
    get top quality arthritis medication for dog around
  • Response
    click here for top quality search engine ready work anywhere
  • Response
    How does blogging/setting up a blog help a small to meduim size business grow?
  • Response
    Which program is better and designing and creating an online magazine? Joomla or WordPress?
  • Response
    How do I become a blogger in the food and drink category?
  • Response
    Where can I start a personal blog about anything & everything?
  • Response
    Any recomendations on how to start a blog for teens?
  • Response
    go here for best symptoms of arthritis around
  • Response
    i want to start a website to sell my beaded jewelry but i dont know how to start website so if u have any ideas or frnds that u know please tell me i really nee help or if u have any frnds that like wearing jewelry please tell me to ...
  • Response
    I have been told to improve your creative writing you need to read a lot.. What great classic books, can I read (from any period or country) that will improve my writing.. Genre is unimportant, though I am not writing for children.. I said classic, I read science fiction/recent literature as ...
  • Response
    see here for greatest life insurance for children around
  • Response
    click here for top quality posicionamiento en buscadores around
  • Response
    go here for greatest mortgage life insurance around
  • Response
    go here for top quality dog s arthritis around
  • Response
    Response: visite site
    How can I get more people to visit my blogger site?
  • Response
    "[...]- Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"[...]"
  • Response
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    Response: india properties
    I need to start a free website and need information on where to go to get it started. Any info about starting a website is welcome!.
  • Response
    I have a weird desire now to make a false blog. What is a good blog site to do this and let people know that its not really my thoughts but of my characters thoughts?.
  • Response
    Response: orthomol vitamin u
    "[...]- Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"[...]"
  • Response
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    Response: best way
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    Response: webpage
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    Response: Joseph Chinnock
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    Response: Joseph Chinnock
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    Response: Guy Hayenga
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    Response: Guy Hayenga
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    Response: Link Schwartz
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    Response: Nishan Kohli
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    Response: Nishan Kohli
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    Response: Nishan Kohli
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    Response: Link Schwartz
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    Response: Guy Hayenga
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    Response: Guy Hayenga
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    Response: ebon talifarro
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    Response: Frank Dellaglio
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"
  • Response
    Response: groupwise inc
    - Navelgazing Midwife Blog - My Take on the MANA Stats "Study"

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>